1-7 Treating Disease

(4483 Reads)

Table of Contents| Chapter Article List| Printable Version | Printable Chapter

[Prev] | [Next]

Learning Objectives

After reading this section, students will be able to...

  1. Describe the practice of Variolation.
  2. Describe Edward Jenner's role in developing the first vaccine.
  3. Explain how Pasteur discovered vaccination as a general practice
  4. Describe what Paul Ehrlich did for17 years.
  5. Explain the contribution of Alexander Fleming.

The power of vaccination is discovered

As soon as it was realized that microbes cause illness, the search was on for ways to kill or to prevent them from causing disease. In this section and the next, we will look at two series of events that illustrate the emergence of modern treatment of infectious disease: the development of vaccines and the discovery of antimicrobial compounds.

Smallpox was a feared disease throughout human history and justifiably so. It was highly contagious and almost everyone eventually became infected. Mortality rates were as high as 25% in adults and closer to 40% in children. Those who did survive often had scarring due to the blister-like pustules that form on the skin, but they obtained life-long immunity to the disease.

As far back at the 11thcentury in India and China it was realized that liquid from the pustules of a smallpox victim, when scratched on the skin of a healthy patient, would most often cause mild disease. This intentional infection, termed variolation, would also give life-long protection against the virus. Lady Mary Wortley Montgue, wife of ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, introduced variolation to England in 1721 and it became a popular practice throughout Europe. Washington even began variolating the Continental Army in 1776.

Variolation had some deleterious side effects. Serious skin lesions inevitably resulted at the site of inoculation, often accompanied by a generalized rash or even a full case of smallpox. The fatality rate from variolation was 1 to 2 %. Today we would find this level of fatality to be unacceptable, but at the time this risk still represented a significant advance.

In 1796, Edward Jenner, an English country physician pictured in Figure 1.15, went in search of a more predictable and safer method of protection against the disease. He noticed that milkmaids rarely contracted smallpox. Further investigation revealed they often contracted cowpox from their charges. Jenner hypothesized that cowpox was related to smallpox and contraction of the former would protect against the latter. In a classic experiment (and one that would land you in jail today), Jenner inoculated a young patient with cowpox and later challenged him with smallpox. The boy did not become ill and Jenner was responsible for the creation of a safer method of protection against smallpox. It is important to stress that the nature of these diseases and their viruses would not be known for over 100 years. Jenner was ahead of his time.

Edward Jenner

Figure 1.15. Edward Jenner. The English physician who developed a safer method for protecting against smallpox. We would now call this a vaccine. Drawing by Tammi Henke.

Beginning around 1876 Pasteur's studies on chicken cholera led to the development of vaccines to fight the disease. Cholera was a serious problem since it was able to spread through a barnyard and wipe out a flock in as little as 3 days. It was transmitted by contaminated food or animal excrement. Pasteur identified the cholera bacillus and grew it in pure culture. When injected with it, a chicken invariably died within 48 hours.

Then, as often happens in scientific research, luck intervened. During the heat of the summer, Pasteur returned to Paris and left the cholera cultures used for infection stored on the shelves of his laboratory in Arbois, France. Upon returning, something had happened to the cultures, they no longer caused disease when tested in chickens. With some impatience for the time they were wasting, his group set to work making new cultures of the bacillus and tested these batches on both new birds and also those previously inoculated with the ineffective strain. To their amazement the previously injected birds were unaffected by the fresh bacillus culture, while the new birds all died. Pasteur immediately realized that this was similar to the studies of Jenner.

Pasteur then developed a method for creating cultures that would confer immunity, but not cause disease. Sometimes this involved growing the microbe in medium in the laboratory where they would spontaneously loose their virulence. In other cases it involved multiple passes through a susceptible host. For example, the rabies virus was attenuated by passing it through rabbits. In honor of Jenner's accomplishments Pasteur coined the term vaccination (vacca = cow in Latin) for the process of immunization against disease. In this and several of Pasteur's other discoveries, luck played a part, but it was only helpful because he tenaciously pursued "odd" results and had the insight to arrive at important conclusions. In Pasteur's famous words, " In the field of observation, chance favors only the prepared mind."

Pasteur's technique of weakening a strain by a damaging treatment or passing it through a susceptible host was termed attenuation and resulted in the creation of vaccines against anthrax, plague, yellow fever, rabies and many other diseases. Many vaccines have been developed over the years and children today receive a number of shots, greatly decreasing infant mortality.

Antimicrobial compounds are developed to kill microorganisms

We now pick up another thread though the web of microbial history that began with the work of Paul Ehrlich. By 1885, it was becoming clear that the causative agents of many illnesses were microorganisms. As scientists manipulated these microbes in the lab they found that certain dyes and other compounds were able to inhibit their growth. This inspired Paul Ehrlich to propose that chemicals may exist that kill the microbe, but not the patient, thus curing the illness.

One of the diseases Ehrlich hoped to cure was syphilis, which had reached epidemic proportions in Europe. Little did he realize it would be a 17-year odyssey before he would develop salvarsan, the first effective chemotherapeutic agent. Salvarsan was the 606thchemical he tried. This arsenic compound effectively kills Treponema pallidum, the causative agent of syphilis.

The treatment, however, had many problems, causing long lasting health complications for those individuals who used it. In addition, despite Treponema being quite sensitive to salvarsan, the physician had to administer it intravenously for optimum effectiveness. Intravenous injection was a recent development and many doctors were leery of trying the procedure. In London, a young physician by the name of Alexander Fleming, then in the Army Medical Corps, was one of the few that was willing to treat patients. Fleming even got the nickname private 606 from his burgeoning practice. His work validated the effectiveness of salvarsan against syphilis and convinced others to administer the treatment.

Fleming, pictured in Figure 1.16, was a physician by training, but spent most of his time studying bacteria, and his success with salvarsan motivated him to search for other antibacterial agents. His first discovery was lysozyme, an enzyme produced by many organisms including humans, which lysed some bacteria. This enzyme is not useful as a therapeutic agent because it is difficult to administer as a drug, but Fleming did develop titration methods and assays that would become very useful.

Alexander Fleming

Figure 1.16. Alexander Fleming. The young English physician who discovered the antibiotic penicillin. Drawing by Tammi Henke.

Fleming's arguably most important contribution to science is his discovery of penicillin. In September of 1928, before leaving on a summer holiday, Fleming streaked some plates of Staphylococcus aureus and left them to incubate until his return. In an improbable set of circumstances, the beginning of the holiday was cold, allowing some contaminating mold spores (that had blown in from a nearby window) to grow up on some of the plates. The temperature then increased encouraging the growth of the Staphylococcus. Many experimenters when confronted with a contaminated plate look for the trash bin, but Fleming instead spent some time examining it. The fungus had a zone of clearing around it where the Staphylococcus colonies would not grow, suggesting the fungus was producing an antibacterial compound that had diffused into the medium. Intrigued, he cultured the fungus, a Penicillium mold, and eventually isolated a soluble extract that could kill bacteria and treat localized infection. He called the new compound penicillin after the mold from which it came. Due to the technology then available, however, it was very difficult to prepare a solution that could be used throughout the body without causing problems.

World War II added a greater urgency to the search for compounds that could fight infectious disease. Wounded soldiers, if they survived the initial injury, would often develop life-threatening infections and there were no effective drugs to combat them. In 1939 Howard Florey and Ernst Chain began a systematic study of antimicrobial compounds in hopes of developing treatments for these soldiers and ran across Fleming's report written 9 years earlier. They now were able to purify the compound completely and describe its high potency against microbes. The availability of penicillin during World War II saved countless lives. The rediscovery of penicillin touched off a search for other microbes producing substances that could kill or inhibit microbes, leading to the discovery of many more antimicrobials. With Florey and Chain, Fleming was awarded the Noble prize in Medicine and Physiology in 1945.

In the ensuing decades the search and discovery of numerous antimicrobial compounds, combined with the development of vaccines, has eliminated many of the deadly diseases that plagued humankind. While we now realize this is a continuing war and not a one-time battle, our understanding of these microbes and the nature of disease will likely keep infectious disease at bay for the foreseeable future. Table 1.5 lists important events in the treatment and prevention of disease.

Table 1.5. Treatment and prevention of disease

Year Event
1100 Physicians in India and China realize that the liquid from the pustules of a smallpox victim, when scratched on the skin of a healthy patient, would most often cause mild disease. This intentional infection, termed variolation, would also give life-long protection against the illness.
1721 Lady Mary Wortley Montgue, wife of the ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, introduces variolation to Europe.
1796 Edward Jenner uses cowpox to immunize against smallpox.
1884 Ilya Ilich Metchnikoff demonstrates that certain body cells move to damaged areas of the body where they consume bacteria and other foreign particles. He calls the process phagocytosis. This is the beginning of the science of immunology, the study of the immune system.
1885 Paul Ehrlich proposes that certain chemicals affect bacterial cells and begins a search for one that can treat syphilis.
1886 Theobald Smith and D. E. Salmon develop a treatment for hog cholera by injecting killed hog cholera microorganisms into pigeons and demonstrate immunity to subsequent administration of a live microbial culture of cholera.
1891 Ehrlich shows that antibodies are responsible for part of immunity.
1897 Almwroth Wright and David Sample develop an effective vaccine against typhoid fever using killed cells of Salmonella typhi.
1897 Waldemar Haffkine develops a vaccine against the plague.
1912 Paul Ehrlich announces the discovery of a cure for syphilis. The cure is the first specific chemotherapeutic agent for a bacterial disease.
1929 Alexander Fleming publishes the first paper describing penicillin.
1935 Gerhard J. Domagk uses Prontosil, a chemically synthesized antimetabolite, to kill Streptococcus in mice.
1938 Max Theiler produces a vaccine against yellow fever by passaging the virus through mice to weaken it.
1940 Howard Florey and Ernest Chain produce an extract of penicillin and show it can kill bacteria in animals.
1940 Ernest Chain and E.P. Abraham describe a substance from E. coli that can inactivate penicillin. This demonstrates how rapidly bacteria can become resistant to antibiotics.
1940 Selman Waksman and H. Boyd Woodruff discover actinomycin, the first antibiotic obtained pure from a group of soil organisms, the actinomycetes. In subsequent years many antibiotics are isolated from this group including tetracycline and streptomycin.
1941 Charles Fletcher demonstrates that penicillin is non-toxic to human volunteers, by injecting a police officer suffering from a lethal infection.
1942 Selman Waksman suggests the word "antibiotic" to describe the class of compounds produced by one microorganism that inhibit or kill other microorganisms.
1944 Albert Schatz, E. Bugie, and Selman Waksman discover streptomycin, a very effective drug against tuberculosis.
1944 W. H. Feldman and H. C. Hinshaw at the Mayo Clinic successfully treat tuberculosis with streptomycin.
1957 The Soviet delegation to the World Health Organization proposes a vaccination effort to eradicate smallpox. The program finally begins in 1967.
1977 Ali Maow Maalin, age 23 of Somalia, is the last known victim of naturally occurring smallpox.
1979 Smallpox is declared to be eliminated. This is the only example of a microbial disease that has been wiped from the face of the Earth. (However, the recent specter of bioterrorism and the smallpox stocks kept by several governments make new epidemics of smallpox still possible.)

Key Takeaways

  1. Variolation, immunization against smallpox, was a common practice before vaccination was common. This worked because the patient was exposed to a weak strain of smallpox, which did not kill, yet provided immunity to the disease.
  2. Edward Jenner discovered that cowpox could protect against smallpox, with a much lower incidence of complications than variolation.
  3. Pasteur discovered a general method for immunizing people against disease while working on chicken cholera. He coined the term vaccination to describe the technique.
  4. Paul Ehrlich spent 17 years in search of a chemical treatment against syphilis, eventually discovering salvarsan.
  5. Alexander Fleming discovered the first antibiotic, penicillin.
[Prev] | [Next]

Table of Contents| Chapter Article List| Printable Version Printable Chapter

1. Why would Jenner's cowpox experiment have "landed him in jail today."

2. Jenner must have been an ethical man, so why do you suppose he even considered doing the experiment at the time?

3. Arsenic is certainly a human poison, but it was a moderately successful drug because

A. Treponema is less sensitive to arsenic than humans are.
B. Treponema is more sensitive to arsenic than humans are.
C. Treponema is resistant to arsenic
D. Arsenic is not toxic to humans
E. None of the above

Grade Quiz

No comments posted yet.

Only logged in users are allowed to comment. Register or log in.

Subscribe to the Book

You need to register first before you can subscribe to the book. To do this go to the registration page